When Christians Behave Badly

The doctrine of sin is the most empirically verifiable Christian belief. Pick up any newspaper or think about the history of the twentieth century on into the twenty-first and you will encounter ample evidence that something is wrong with human nature. If we are honest with ourselves and engage in a little introspection, we must admit our own selfishness, occasional acts of unkindness, and wrong attitudes towards others. Our consciences tell us that we have each violated our own standard of right and wrong in some way.

In recent times, we have heard about pedophile priests, hypocritical church leaders, and swindling televangelists. When those who claim to be Christians lead double lives, manipulate others, or betray the values they profess to believe and live by, the disgust we feel for this hypocrisy indicates a recognition of the ethical standards that have been violated. I can offer the following thoughts about this problem:

  1. Bad behavior must be recognized as such. It is not caused by the faith; it is a violation or betrayal of the faith.
  2. Those antagonistic to the Christian faith will quickly say, "Ah ha! It's all a sham and a delusion." But, if faith was about living up to a given set of laws and in our pride setting ourselves apart from the "damned masses" by our superior lives, they might have a point. However, the central message of the Christian faith is redemption from sin and the separation from God that results from it. Christian faith is first and foremost about God's mercy to a sinful humanity. To the proud Pharisees, Christ stated with muted sarcasm, "Those who are well have no need of a physician." The normal weaknesses and human foibles of people in the churches is not the same as hypocrisy.
  3. The offer of mercy and grace in no way excuses hypocrisy or bad behavior. Christ certainly demands a high standard of behavior---in fact, the Sermon on the Mount presents an impossibly high standard designed to drive us to God's mercy. However, Christianity is not primarily about keeping laws and adhering to ethical standards, even though that is important. It is about living in gratitude for God's mercy and forgiveness, which comes through Christ. However, grace does NOT lead to license ("I'm forgiven, so I can live anyway I want to"). The Apostle Paul stated, "How can we who died to sin, still live in it?"
  4. While media attention is focused on those who betray faith, we must remember that for every failed leader there are masses of faithful, well-meaning leaders and Christian folk who strive to live their faith with sincerity and integrity. No one claims to be perfect.

Back to Articles Page